NHL Rival League?

The Puck Stops Here has written numerous articles about how many Russians are returning to Russia to play hockey partly because of the lack of a transfer agreement with Russia, CBA related issues and because the Russian league can offer many of them equal or greater salaries. In a recent article about a Canadian leaving to play for Russia I wrote a comment about the impact of all these players returning to Russia might have on the Russian league. I wondered if with all these players returning to Russia if the Russian league is seeing growth in the fan base as well as revenue. I also wondered if any such success may enourage them to expand beyond the Russian borders and create a European Super League. This seems even more possible when you consider that the other European countries recently voted to end the current IIHF transfer agreement with the NHL and renegotiate a better one.

Well just four days after I wondered if a European super league may get started TSN and the Toronto Star are reporting that a Russian Tycoon has hired former NHLPA executive Bob Goodenow to help create a new professional European hockey league which could start as soon as September 2008. This is bad news for Bettman and the NHL as we have heard whispers that a European division of the NHL was a goal of theirs. If this league takes off and a significant number of European players return to Europe or remain in Europe what impact will that have on the quality of the on ice product in which many people already feel is sub-par because of diluted level of talent. Mass mediocrity and a general lack of high quality teams rules the roost in the NHL today if even 20% of europeans leave the NHL it could be disaster for the on ice product. If you thought scoring was low in the NHL now, imagine what it will be with 20% fewer skilled Europeans.

James Mirtle has a related story on the reduction of Europeans in the NHL.

Posted in NHL

This article has 4 Comments

  1. I don’t see it. Most of the players who’ve gone back to their home country have done so because they can’t cut it here. The pay is still potentially more lucrative in the US and Canada, and so the US and Canada are still going to get the best players.

    Diluted talent is, of course, a strawman – goaltending talent is better than ever, and so are defenses. If anything, the talent isn’t dilute enough – there’s too many good goalies and defenders. The league needs more Norm Macivers to give the opposition breakaway chances, and more Robb Staubers who wouldn’t get a sniff at the NHL now.

  2. There seems to be the illusion that all players from the other side of the ocean want to play in the NHL butt his is not true. Lots of Russians can make more money and play their own game ie. creat offesne rather than come play for Vignaeult, Nolan and defensive guys like that. the laegue will wrok if they look at what is wrong with the NHL game ie too much coaching, defesive systems and huge goalie pads, if they creat a dynamic offesnive league it will draw talent over there and they can coexist with the NHL

  3. if the russians were so “skilled and creative,” they’d win more internationally, now wouldn’t they?

    This league will go down as a diluted joke that will eventually go belly-up; let’s hope the country of Russia follows it into oblivion, too

  4. besides, as american talent emerges that is every bit the equal of russian and eastern european talent, the need for (largely) mediocre european talent will subside. Sure, every once in a while an Ovechkin or Malkin will emerge, but there are a lot of poor Euros in the league rght now who are drawing a pay-check solely it seems because they’re not from places like Red Deer. I mean, Jiri Tlusty in the National Hockey League? The make-me-laughs have at least a dozen Canadian kids they could bring up who would do a better job and wouldn’t flash their bits on myspace.

Comments are closed.